Controversial
Nadir Claims Hadith Superior to Quran Based on Scientific Miracles Alone
Modern Day Debates
DEBATE: Is the Hadith Essential to Quran? Sunni Vs Quran-Only
"The Hadith is better than the Quran from a scientific point of view. From its totality. From the eyes of God. The hadith is better because people like you are urinating upon themselves."
In a Muslim-versus-Muslim debate, Nadir argued that the Hadith is a superior guide to the Quran because of scientific miracles within it, including predictions about Arabia becoming green and the presence of alcohol in blood. He claimed the Hadith provides essential health guidance—such as avoiding zoonotic diseases and proper hygiene—that the Quran alone does not offer. This position contradicts mainstream Sunni theology, which holds the Quran to be God's final and perfect revelation.
From this episode
Modern Day Debates