Controversial
Debater Argues Quran Requires Mosaic Revelation Like Torah and Hadith
Modern Day Debates
DEBATE: Is the Hadith Essential to Quran? Sunni Vs Quran-Only
"The Quran said bring a book better than the Torah and the Quran. Hadith is a better guide than the Torah. Even if it has all these problems which you are claiming it does, it doesn't matter because the price is worth it."
Nadir invoked Quran 28:49 to argue that the Quran itself points to a 'mosaic revelation'—a combination of divine word and human transmission, like the Torah—and that the Hadith fulfills this role today. He maintained that even if the Hadith contains contradictions or errors, it is still essential because it offers critical guidance for humanity, such as cures for diseases. His opponent Muhammad rejected this interpretation, insisting the Quran is complete and self-sufficient.
From this episode
Modern Day Debates