Second Ransom Note Revealed: Nancy Guthrie Perished Shortly After Abduction, Buried With Nature
"We never intended to hurt her in all of this. She perished shortly after she was taken. She was buried with nature. Nothing you could have done could have changed the outcome, and we are truly sorry."
About this episode
Ashley Banfield hosts a detailed examination of major new developments in the Nancy Guthrie kidnapping investigation on Drop Dead Serious, now airing on NewsNation's YouTube channel. CBS News has released previously confidential details from the ransom notes, including that the first note directly addressed Savannah Guthrie by name with the greeting 'Hello Savannah, we have your mother Nancy' and contained specific knowledge of Nancy's Apple Watch location in her bedroom. Reporter Brianna Whitney, who worked for Arizona Family television at the time and had direct access to the second ransom note, discloses its exact wording for the first time: the abductors admitted Nancy 'perished shortly after she was taken' and was 'buried with nature,' expressing remorse and claiming they underestimated her fragile condition. The unusual phrasing suggests possible non-native English speakers or use of translation software. Banfield interviews retired homicide detective Chris McDonough, who has a 90% solve rate from 13 years in homicide investigation. McDonough reveals a critical failure in the investigation: 144 days after Nancy's abduction, Pima County Sheriff's Department has not contacted Tucson Police Department's street informant teams, a standard practice for gathering intelligence. McDonough identifies a new investigative lead: Annie Guthrie's jewelry workshop is located in a high-crime area near a foundation supporting released prisoners, suggesting this could be where perpetrators identified Nancy as a target through overheard conversations. TMZ's Harvey Levin reports FBI linguistic analysis suggests a woman may be behind secondary extortion attempts from someone claiming to know the perpetrators' identities. McDonough explains the ransom demands are highly unusual, with immediate threats and escalating amounts being extremely rare in legitimate kidnapping cases, suggesting the notes may be 'noise' created after Nancy's accidental death to cover the crime.
Key takeaways
- CBS News releases exact wording of ransom note that opened with 'Hello Savannah' and referenced specific location of Nancy Guthrie's Apple Watch in her bedroom
- Reporter Brianna Whitney discloses second ransom note admitted Nancy 'perished shortly after she was taken' and was 'buried with nature' using unusual phrasing
- Retired detective Chris McDonough reveals Pima County Sheriff has not contacted Tucson Police street informant teams 144 days into investigation
- McDonough identifies Annie Guthrie's jewelry workshop location in high-crime area near ex-prisoner foundation as potential contact point where perpetrators identified Nancy
- FBI linguistic analysis suggests woman may be behind secondary extortion attempts from person claiming to know perpetrators and burial location
- First ransom note demanded $4 million escalating to $6 million with immediate threat to kill Nancy, which McDonough calls extremely rare and suspicious
- McDonough theorizes multiple perpetrators with different roles including 'porch guy' as muscle, driver, and third person managing communications and ransom demands