← All stories
Faith & Spirituality

Jimmy Akin alleges James White’s Apocrypha argument relies on outdated scholarship

By Egleze Editorial Desk · Published September 18, 2026 · Pints with Aquinas · Jimmy Akin DESTROYS James White | Last Call Ep. 32
Jimmy Akin alleges James White’s Apocrypha argument relies on outdated scholarship
Pints with Aquinas
Pints with Aquinas
Jimmy Akin DESTROYS James White | Last Call Ep. 32

What was said

"James White is relying on the views of one particular author named Beckwith who um wrote several decades ago and that's a long time in scholarship. He was like writing back in the 1980s. And Beckwith uniquely among compared to other scholars argued that the Jews had a registry of some kind in the temple of all of the books that they considered scripture."

Catholic apologist Jimmy Akin alleges Protestant apologist James White’s claim about Jews “laying up” books in the Temple relies on 1980s scholarship by Roger Beckwith. Akin says Beckwith’s Temple “registry” idea is widely rejected and argues Jewish views of Scripture were not settled in that period.

Verification status

Attributed speaker claim

Egleze verified who said this and where. The underlying claim has not been independently established by Egleze.

Source and context

Egleze verified who said this and where. The underlying claim has not been independently established by Egleze.

Speaker
Jimmy Akin · guest
Programme
Pints with Aquinas
Episode
Jimmy Akin DESTROYS James White | Last Call Ep. 32
Clip time
24:24
Original source
Watch the source segment →
From this episode
Pints with Aquinas
Pints with Aquinas

Jimmy Akin DESTROYS James White | Last Call Ep. 32

September 17, 2026 · 28m · 2 Egleze moments
Read episode summary and key points →

More moments from this episode

Faith & SpiritualityJimmy Akin argues Second Temple Judaism lacked a single agreed canon→
More stories More from Pints with Aquinas