Canadian Same-Sex Couple Sues Surrogate Who Refused Abortion Demand Over Cleft Lip

About this episode

Ben Shapiro, host of The Ben Shapiro Show, dedicated a monologue episode to defending Western civilization's foundational belief in the inherent value of the individual soul, framed through his personal experience of witnessing the birth of his fifth child. Shapiro centered his argument on a viral clip from the Daily Wire show Pints with Aquinas, in which Boston College philosophy professor Dr. Peter Kreeft emotionally recounted falling in love with his late wife again upon seeing her body after death, arguing that true love must be directed toward the soul rather than the physical body. Shapiro connected this philosophy to biblical teachings from Genesis, the Declaration of Independence, and the American conception of God-given individual rights, positioning the recognition of the soul as the defining characteristic that makes Western civilization morally superior. He contrasted this view with two rival civilizations: secular utilitarian societies that treat people as disposable tools, and collectivist tyrannies like China and Russia that subordinate individual worth to state power. Shapiro cited a Canadian lawsuit in which a same-sex couple is suing their surrogate for refusing to abort their child over a cleft lip as evidence of utilitarian moral decay. He also framed American foreign policy as uniquely moral because it spreads values of individual dignity rather than purely pursuing national interest. The episode blended personal reflection, biblical exegesis, and political commentary to argue that preserving the concept of the soul is essential to defending American and Western identity against both nihilism and authoritarianism.