Putin Keeps Nabiullina as Central Bank Chief Due to Personal Loyalty
"Putin never forgets these things. He's always fiercely loyal to the people who execute for him and he's never in my opinion going to sack her and so long as Nabulina wants to remain head of the central bank. She will she will continue in that position and she will always be overcautious on interest rate policy. It's a reality that anybody who deals with the Russian economy has to accept."
About this episode
Alexander and his host discuss Russia's central bank interest rate policy and its impact on economic growth, with a focus on mounting criticism from major business leaders. Despite apparent positive economic indicators including wealth growth of 37 percent between 2020 and 2025 and rising real wages, Central Bank chief Elvira Nabiullina maintains real interest rates at 10 percent, which critics argue is strangling small and medium-sized businesses. German Gref, CEO of Sberbank, Russia's largest bank owned by the central bank itself, publicly stated the economy has been overcooled and cannot sustain such high rates long-term. Alexander explains that while larger industrial groups like Rosneft and Rosatom fund operations through retained profits and are unaffected, small businesses and consumers face loan rates of 12-20 percent. Nabiullina's recent half-point cut from 15 to 14.5 percent is essentially meaningless as falling inflation maintains the same real rate gap. Alexander reveals this pattern mirrors 2014-2019 when Nabiullina kept real rates at 5 percent for five years until Putin personally intervened. He argues she believes the economy is at full capacity and any rate reduction would cause overheating and inflation, while critics like Gref contend significant spare capacity exists. The most significant revelation is that Putin will not replace Nabiullina regardless of economic criticism due to her past loyalty and execution during critical moments, including stabilizing the economy in 2022 and cleaning up the banking system. Alexander suggests Putin may eventually intervene again, possibly in 2026, but emphasizes that personal loyalty trumps performance concerns in Russian leadership decisions.
Key takeaways
- Sberbank CEO German Gref publicly stated Russia's central bank has overcooled the economy with 10 percent real interest rates that businesses cannot sustain long-term.
- Russia's Central Bank chief Elvira Nabiullina maintains punishingly high real interest rates despite falling inflation, with small businesses paying 12-20 percent on loans.
- Putin will not replace Nabiullina as central bank head due to personal loyalty despite widespread criticism of her overcautious monetary policy.
- Average wealth in Russia increased 37 percent between 2020 and 2025 while median wealth grew just over 9 percent, according to UBS figures.
- Nabiullina's recent half-point rate cut from 15 to 14.5 percent is essentially meaningless as the real interest rate remains unchanged at 10 percent.
- Russia experienced economic contraction in January-February 2025, rebounded in March-April, dipped again in May, then showed expansion in June with PMI reading of 50.3.
- Putin previously intervened in 2019 to force Nabiullina to cut rates after she maintained 5 percent real interest rates for five years, and may do so again next year.