America is more racially progressive than Europe according to callback studies
"The best way to measure racial discrimination is through callback studies, sending resumes to employers that are identical except for racially coded names. One of the largest ever callback studies found that Europeans exhibited more racial discrimination against black people than Americans did."
About this episode
This monologue addresses the tension around American patriotism as the country approaches its 250th birthday, focusing on why progressives struggle to celebrate America despite compelling evidence for doing so. The speaker challenges recent comments by Joy Reid and the historical claims of Nikole Hannah-Jones's 1619 Project, particularly the assertion that the American Revolution was fought to preserve slavery and that African Americans fought back alone against white supremacy. He argues these claims are historically false, noting that the American Revolution actually sparked anti-slavery sentiment, that the oldest abolition society was founded in Pennsylvania in 1775, and that white and Jewish allies played crucial roles in civil rights, including comprising more than half of NAACP founding members. The speaker contends that progressive ideology struggles with patriotism because it takes for granted precious achievements like wealth creation, rule of law, and political rights while fixating on imperfections. He offers progressives two data-driven reasons for patriotism: America remains the top destination for global migrants, especially from the global south that progressives prioritize, and comparative studies show America is more racially progressive than Europe, Latin America, Africa, and the Middle East. Poll data shows this divide starkly, with 92% of Republicans proud to be American versus only 36% of Democrats, a gap the speaker argues threatens national cohesion and must be bridged through shared patriotic pride.
Key takeaways
- Joy Reid recently dismissed Fourth of July celebrations as honoring slaveholders, while Nikole Hannah-Jones's 1619 Project claimed the Revolution aimed to preserve slavery, both assertions the speaker challenges as historically false.
- More NAACP founding members were white or Jewish than black, and Jews comprised half of non-black northern volunteers in 1964's Freedom Summer, contradicting Hannah-Jones's claim that blacks fought back alone against white supremacy.
- The American Revolution sparked unprecedented anti-slavery sentiment globally, with the world's oldest abolition society founded in Pennsylvania in 1775, not coincidentally after the Revolution began.
- America remains the top destination for global migrants at 15%, with 24% of sub-Saharan Africans and 28% of Latin Americans choosing America first, demonstrating revealed preferences over rhetoric.
- The largest callback studies measuring hiring discrimination found Europeans exhibit more racial discrimination against black people than Americans do, contradicting narratives of exceptional American racism.
- America has elected a black president while most Latin American countries with African-descended populations have not, and tolerance surveys show America far more progressive than Africa and the Middle East.
- Only 36% of Democrats say they are proud to be American compared to 92% of Republicans, a patriotism gap the speaker warns threatens national cohesion as America celebrates its 250th birthday.